How Should Small Businesses Handle Sickness Absence? Advice For SME Employers
Sickness absence can be particularly challenging for small businesses, where the unexpected loss of even one member of staff can leave colleagues covering additional work, disrupt customer service and put pressure on already stretched teams.
But while SMEs need to know as quickly as possible when somebody is unable to work, employers should balance the practical needs of the business with a fair and supportive approach to the employee concerned.
HR software provider BrightHR says it should generally be standard practice for employees to speak directly to their manager when reporting sickness absence. However, small businesses are also being reminded to use common sense and make appropriate adjustments where a telephone conversation would create a genuine barrier.
The issue has come under the spotlight following remarks by Sir Charlie Mayfield, former chairman of John Lewis, who was reported in The Times calling for employees to contact their managers directly when they are unable to work because of illness.
For SME owners, a direct conversation can be particularly useful. It gives managers an early opportunity to understand the likely impact of an absence, arrange cover, redistribute urgent work and establish whether the employee needs additional support.
However, businesses should avoid treating a telephone call as an inflexible requirement regardless of the circumstances.
Alan Price, CEO at BrightHR, said:
“I agree with Sir Charlie about the value of a direct conversation when an employee is off sick. Speaking to a manager helps both sides understand what’s needed, whether that’s arranging cover, discussing workload or making sure the employee has the right support.
“However, employers need to apply common sense. There will be situations where a phone call isn’t practical or appropriate, for example where someone is seriously unwell, receiving hospital treatment, has a disability that makes phone communication difficult, or is experiencing a mental health condition that makes a call particularly challenging.
“In those circumstances, employers should be prepared to make reasonable adjustments and consider other appropriate ways for the employee to report their absence.”
Have A Clear Sickness Absence Procedure
One of the most useful steps a small business can take is to establish a straightforward procedure for reporting sickness.
Employees should know who they are expected to contact, when they need to make contact and how they should do so. The procedure should also explain what happens if the employee is too unwell to follow the normal process.
Having clear rules can be particularly valuable for SMEs, where HR responsibilities may fall to the business owner, office manager or another senior employee rather than a dedicated HR department.
Consistency is important too. Applying dramatically different expectations to different members of staff can create confusion and potentially lead to disputes.
Don’t Make The Sickness Call An Interrogation
A conversation with an absent employee should help the employer establish the information genuinely needed to manage the situation.
For a small business, that could include whether there are urgent jobs or customer commitments that need to be handed over, whether cover is required and, where possible, when the employee expects to provide a further update.
The conversation should not become an attempt to challenge whether somebody is genuinely ill.
Managers should also remember that employees may be discussing sensitive health information. Any details provided should be handled appropriately and only shared where necessary.
Be Prepared To Use Other Forms Of Communication
Although speaking directly can often be the quickest way to deal with an unexpected absence, SMEs should avoid assuming that every employee will always be capable of making a telephone call.
Serious illness, hospital treatment, disability or some mental health conditions could make calling difficult or inappropriate.
Depending on the circumstances, another method of communication may be more suitable. The important point for the employer is to establish what has happened and maintain appropriate contact without creating unnecessary barriers for somebody who is already unwell.
Plan For Absence Before It Happens
Small businesses can also reduce disruption by considering how essential work would be covered before an employee becomes unavailable.
Making sure more than one person understands critical processes, keeping important information accessible to the appropriate people and identifying who can take responsibility for urgent tasks can make an unexpected absence considerably easier to manage.
For very small teams, this can be especially important. Relying entirely on one individual for a critical business function can leave an SME vulnerable not only to sickness absence but also holidays and other unexpected circumstances.
Keep In Touch Without Putting Employees Under Pressure
Where an absence continues beyond a day or two, employers may need to agree how and when further contact will take place.
The appropriate level of contact will depend on the circumstances. A prolonged absence is likely to require a different approach from a short-term illness where the employee expects to return quickly.
For SMEs, the aim should be to maintain enough communication to manage the business effectively while avoiding unnecessary or excessive contact that could make an employee feel pressured to return before they are ready.
A Good Policy Protects The Business And Its People
Sickness absence will affect virtually every small employer at some point, and SMEs may feel its operational impact particularly quickly.
Having a clear procedure, training managers to handle conversations sensitively and allowing reasonable flexibility can help businesses respond consistently when an employee is unable to work.
Direct communication between an employee and their manager can be valuable, particularly when a small team needs to rearrange workloads quickly. But as BrightHR stresses, employers should also recognise when circumstances require a different approach.
For SMEs, the most effective sickness absence policy is likely to be one that provides enough structure to protect the business while retaining the flexibility needed to treat employees fairly and supportively.
