November 20, 2026
Data decisions

Written by David Tyler

Data-driven decision making has captured the imagination of business leaders everywhere, and for good reason. The promise is compelling: use information to make better choices across every part of your organisation, from sales strategies to operational efficiency.

It’s an appealing concept that feels both modern and logical. Yet despite widespread enthusiasm and significant investment, many organisations struggle to see the transformational results they expected.

The issue isn’t with the concept itself, but with how it’s commonly understood and implemented.  Most companies approach data-driven decision making in what seems like the obvious sequence: collect the data first, then use it to make decisions. This interpretation feels natural – after all, the phrase itself suggests that data comes before decisions. But this fundamental misunderstanding of the process is precisely where things start to go wrong.

The approach gets you moving quickly. Your tech team can dive straight into building impressive platforms to process vast amounts of data. The analytics team can start crunching numbers immediately. Executives get regular updates filled with charts and statistics. Everyone stays busy, technology gets deployed, and there’s a tangible sense of momentum.

But this activity often masks a complete lack of direction. We’re confusing motion with progress, embarking on expensive journeys without knowing our destination – or even having a map.

The data hoarding trap

What actually happens in most organisations is far more problematic than poor navigation. It’s data hoarding on an industrial scale. Companies become obsessed with collecting everything they possibly can, convincing themselves that somewhere in these mountains of information lies the answer to all their problems. The psychology is understandable: we’ve paid good money for this data, so surely it must be valuable. Storage is cheap, processing power is abundant, so why not keep everything? Before long, organisations find themselves buried under vast quantities of largely useless information, but they can’t bear to delete it because of the sunk cost.

This digital hoarding creates its own problems. Teams spend countless hours maintaining systems that store data nobody uses. Analysts waste time sifting through irrelevant information looking for something meaningful. Decision-makers get overwhelmed by reports that contain everything except what they actually need to know.

Start with decisions, then find the data

The real challenge isn’t collecting data – it’s understanding what decisions your organisation actually makes and how those choices currently happen. This requires stepping back and asking some hard questions:

  • Who makes the critical decisions in your business?
  • Do they have the right training and support?
  • What information do they need to make better choices?
  • When do they need it, and in what format?

Once you’ve mapped out these decision points, you can identify exactly what data would improve each choice. This focused approach eliminates the need for elaborate dashboards displaying every metric imaginable. Instead, you collect only information that directly supports better decision-making.

Failure is part of the process

Even the most thoughtful data-driven approach won’t guarantee perfect decisions. Mistakes are inevitable – the goal is to discover them quickly and cheaply, then adjust course before significant damage occurs. The organisations that succeed with data-driven decision making share a crucial mindset: they actively seek evidence that they might be wrong, rather than defending their initial assumptions. They view early failures as valuable learning opportunities, not career-ending disasters.

The real measure of success

Building impressive technology platforms might look great in progress reports. Having teams busy from day one creates the illusion of productivity. But there’s something far more valuable: making better decisions based on solid evidence, and empowering decision-makers to change direction when the data suggests they should. Unused data isn’t just worthless – it’s actively harmful because it consumes resources without delivering value. The smartest approach focuses on gathering information that directly improves the choices your business makes every day. That’s not just more efficient – it’s actually being data-driven.

—

David Tyler is the Founder of Outlier Technology.