November 21, 2026

Attracting and retaining employees – Are pay and benefits enough?

oval brown wooden conference table and chairs inside conference room

Organisations are experiencing challenges of a grave nature – attraction, retention, and attrition. Leaders are especially flagging increased attrition as a major problem right now, sometimes at significant, even business critical, levels. So, what can organisations do to attract and keep their people right now? Are improved pay and benefits sufficient? John Backhouse, Head of People Science at employee engagement expert WorkBuzz, provides his insights.

Is pay adequate?

The first question asked when leaders fear there’s an employee attraction and retention problem is “are we paying enough?” Many employees have faced unprecedented challenges throughout Covid-19 with rapid disruption to the basics of delivering their jobs, remote working, technology changes, pingdemics, huge resourcing issues, furlough, and job security concerns being just some. Employees are increasingly reflecting on whether pre-Covid pay levels are now adequate for all these additional challenges. Just doing the day-to-day job is so much harder for many, so it’s becoming increasingly more common for employees to question if they are being paid enough for all this additional pressure and workload.

However, it’s been proven time and time again that pay is a temporary motivator. From the perspective of retention, if employees are working so hard that they’re at risk of burnout, are under-resourced and not supported by managers, will a pay rise change any of these things? And increasingly, immediate managers are themselves at high risk of burnout.

How important are benefits and rewards?

Benefits will always play an important role in attracting and keeping people. However, the appealing benefits packages of two years’ ago are quite different to now. What’s important to employees has shifted considerably. Yes, a pension and childcare benefits are still sought, however, Covid-19 has led to many employees reconsidering their priorities – switching careers or thinking of doing so, re-evaluating the importance of a high-flying career compared to wanting a better work-life balance, being more concerned about their health and wellbeing and that of their family.

As found in WorkBuzz’s ‘The State of Employee Engagement 2021 report’, employees are looking for greater flexibility in their roles – both in terms of location and work patterns – wanting greater health and wellbeing benefits – more breaks and more paid leave for example. Right now, there are a lot of very tired employees on the verge of burnout who need respite to re-charge. They are literally at the lowest tiers in the hierarchy of needs, with basic ‘hygiene benefits’, such as rest/holidays and wellbeing support, needed more than ever.

Benefits in isolation aren’t sufficient

Benefits and rewards can’t improve attraction and retention in isolation. The entire employee experience will determine whether a person decides to join and then stay with a company or move on. This means that each individual must feel cared for, appreciated and well-supported by a manager who is invested in them as a person, and in their development. All of the above experienced in an organisation with a clear and inspiring vision and purpose.

Leaders must address organisational purpose – is it inspiring and relatable? They must support flexibility at work, championing an improved work-life balance, while ensuring all managers have been trained to be supportive of every individual’s needs. On top of this, the right systems and processes must be in place to enable effective, frustration-free delivery of each role.

Ultimately, employees are looking for a sense of belonging within a positive culture, with leaders who understand them, ‘have their back’ and acknowledge their plight, being proactive about addressing each and every challenge they face.

Ensure the promise matches the reality

When recruiting staff, it’s easy to make life as an employee sound like it’s all roses and champagne. The problem is that overselling the employee experience is damaging, because if the employee value proposition (EVP) doesn’t match the real EVP, new recruits aren’t going to stick around.

It’s far more costly to sell a false dream, and the person leaves quickly when they realise the reality, compared with selling the real deal and even letting the person experience it before they join. They’ll at least know what they are signing up for.

Be realistic about length of service

‘The Great Resignation’ is causing upset in some organisations and total chaos in others, with attrition at its highest rate for years. In fact, there has been a significant increase in attrition for the one to two-year length of service employees, but even sooner for some organisations.

While it’s important to recognise and remedy the current attrition issue, leaders must also be realistic about levels of employee turnover moving forward. Younger people in particular have different views on careers and how long they want to spend in a role at each organisation. Irrespective of how good an employer is, they may see their career path as spending one to three years at an employer before moving to another. So, in the modern age we live in, might it be an unrealistic expectation to keep hold of talent for longer than three years? Understanding this can then inform and rethink recruitment and onboarding strategy, processes, and career pathways.

A final word

Employees leaving a role will often cite better pay and benefits elsewhere, but this is rarely the whole picture. A company without purpose, the frustrations of the job, a lack of support from the manager who may be at risk of burnout themselves, no or few career discussions, under-resourced teams, inefficient systems, a lack of investment in the work environment, and a toxic and draining culture, are just some of the many analysis-based reasons why people actually leave.

To improve employee attraction and retention, it’s important to look holistically. Address low pay and provide benefits which offer flexibility and wellbeing support but take a look at the whole employee experience to get the full picture, from leadership quality through to delivering a realistic EVP. Only then will you make real strides in creating an attractive and ‘sticky’ workplace.