November 20, 2026
oval brown wooden conference table and chairs inside conference room

Just three out of 10 appeals to the Planning Inspectorate about a ‘convoluted’ tax on property development are successful, according to new research from a property tax specialist.

E3 Consulting analysed every Planning Inspectorate (PINS) judgement about the Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) from January 2020 to July 2021.

The firm found the vast majority of appeals were upheld in favour of local councils, with homeowners and small builders among those losing out.

CIL was introduced to replace Section 106 agreements in planning permissions in England and Wales to fund vital infrastructure, such as roads, parks and GP surgeries.

However, unlike a Section 106 agreement, CIL is non-negotiable with applicants facing a set charge stipulated by the council.

Any exemption or relief – including for self-builders and on developments under 100 sq m – must be gained prior to work starting on site.

It means many who would have been exempt miss out and/or incur penalty surcharges if they unwittingly begin work without the paperwork in place.

Alun Oliver, managing director of Southampton-based E3, said: “The 70 per cent failure rate uncovered in our findings is indicative of just how convoluted and confusing CIL is for many people.

“CIL is highly-procedural and overcomplex, and a lack of understanding leads to time consuming and costly appeals which are largely doomed to failure.

“The process is very time sensitive but sadly a lot of situations lead to costly errors and for the vast majority of those costly errors, the opportunity for relief is lost forever.

“Once a spade has hit the ground and work has started on site it is incredibly difficult to gain any exemption or relief from the CIL charge or win a subsequent appeal.”

Alun added: “Often an appeal is a result of an emotional response to the perceived unfairness of CIL, as it is seemingly a heavy price to pay for relatively small administrative mistakes.

“This response is common however not useful as retrospective action in CIL is fruitless and time consuming.

“Developers and homeowners must be proactive from the very start with CIL or may rue the day they chose to put off dealing with CIL.”

The most common development type affected by CIL is residential, but many councils also apply it to other forms of property, including halls of residence, hotels, retail and offices.

It is a charge calculated per square metre of floorspace and applies to new developments exceeding 100 sq m or creating one or more new dwellings – meaning many homeowners building extensions should be exempt as well as people building their own home.

The exemptions are not automatic and must be applied for before work begins.

E3 conducted its own set of research based on CIL Planning Inspectorate appeals on GOV.uk webpage.

Some 38 per cent of cases involved disputes over the start date of works. Overall, the majority of appeals – 39 out of 65 cases – were made on the basis that a breach did not occur, yet few had grounds or evidence to support their appeal.

E3 advises that any development is evidenced, including proof of postage for documents and photograph of progress on site, or better still emails and electronic receipts comprehensively filed and retained.

Established in 2003, E3 specialises in capital allowances, land remediation tax relief, VAT on real estate, the community infrastructure levy (CIL), and repairs and maintenance deductions.

All of the PINS appeal cases were researched on the gov.uk website.