November 20, 2026

Trade frustrations revealed: scope creep and disruption lead concerns

a person using a paint roller to paint a wall

A new study by Markel Direct, the trades business insurance specialist, had revealed the homeowner behaviours that tradespeople find most frustrating.

The study, which surveyed 500 UK tradespeople on their experiences of working in someone’s home, found that the biggest frustrations centre around disruptions to agreed work. Joint top of the list is being asked to carry out additional tasks not included in the original quote, cited by 31% of tradespeople, with nearly half (47%) saying they experience this regularly. Hovering or closely watching work is equally unpopular, also flagged by 31% as a key annoyance.

Price negotiation follows closely, with 26% of tradespeople identifying it as problematic, and just behind at 25% was not being home at the agreed-upon time.

Top 10 bad homeowner behaviours according to tradespeople

Bad Behaviour

% of tradespeople who find it inconvenient

Asking for extra tasks that weren’t in the agreed quote

31%

Hovering / watching you work

31%

Negotiating price during the job

26%

Not being at home at the agreed arrival time

25%

Pets or children getting in your way while you’re working

23%

Interrupting you during the job

20%

Not clearing the workspace

18%

Refusing access to their toilet

17%

Complaining about mess or noise during a job

16%

Leaving the premises and being unreachable

16%

Beyond inconvenience, some of these behaviours can pose a genuine risk to both tradespeople and homeowners. Pets or children getting in the way (23%), alongside workspaces that haven’t been properly cleared (18%), can create potentially hazardous environments where accidents, damage or injury are more likely. 

Rob Rees, Divisional Director at Markel Direct, said: “Many of the challenges tradespeople face in people’s homes come down to preparation and disruption. When workspaces are cluttered or pets and children are moving around, it not only slows the job down but can also increase the risk of injury or damage. Homeowners can make a real difference by clearing the area in advance, limiting interruptions and agreeing the scope of work upfront. These simple steps help jobs run more efficiently and can reduce the likelihood of issues that lead to delays, disputes or insurance claims.”

Poor behaviour is costing homeowners repeat access to tradespeople

Poor homeowner behaviour can have consequences beyond a single job. More than half (57%) of tradespeople say they have chosen not to work with a customer again due to their behaviour, a potential risk for homeowners in a market where skilled trades are in high demand.

In more serious cases, disputes can arise, with nearly a third (32%) of tradespeople reporting they have been blamed for damage they did not cause.

Together, these findings highlight how poor communication and on-site disruptions can contribute to strained working relationships, reinforcing the importance of clear expectations and good preparation on both sides.

47% of tradespeople say prompt payment is the most valued customer behaviour

When it comes to what tradespeople value most from their customers, paying promptly ranks highest (47%). With many tradespeople running small businesses and managing cash flow from job to job, late payments can cause significant disruption, making timely payment one of the most important aspects of a smooth working relationship.

Following closely behind were being home and ready at the agreed time (45%), alongside trusting professional advice (44%). Together, these behaviours highlight the importance of reliability and trust in helping jobs run efficiently and avoiding unnecessary delays or complications.