November 21, 2026

Zoe Flude, Senior Tax Consultant at Markel Tax examines why accountants should be paying closer attention to HMRC’s increasing use of Schedule 36 powers

Zoe-Flude-image

HMRC’s powers to request information have long formed an important part of the UK’s tax compliance framework. However, there is growing evidence that these powers are being used more frequently, more assertively and, in some cases, in circumstances where their application may be open to challenge.

For accountants and tax advisers, the practical challenge is to identify where legitimate compliance activity ends and disproportionate information gathering begins.

This is becoming increasingly relevant as HMRC invests in compliance activity and data-led investigations. Most taxpayers accept that HMRC needs effective tools to tackle non-compliance, but those tools operate within a legal framework designed to protect taxpayers from unnecessary or excessive intrusion. Understanding where those boundaries lie is therefore essential.

At Markel Tax, we have seen a 10% increase in claims relating to Schedule 36 matters between April 2025 and April 2026. Although this reflects only matters reported to us, it aligns with wider anecdotal evidence from advisers that HMRC is relying on Schedule 36 Notices more frequently and in some cases, at earlier stages of its compliance activity.

It’s a trend worth noting because the consequences of getting it wrong can be significant.  Once information has been disclosed to HMRC, it cannot be undisclosed. A poorly considered response can widen the scope oi a compliance check, create additional lines of enquiry and increase professional costs for both advisers and taxpayers.

The growing use of Schedule 36 powers

HMRC’s primary statutory powers to obtain information are contained within Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008. The legislation allows HMRC to require information and documents that are reasonably required to check a taxpayer’s tax position, but those powers are subject to statutory safeguards and proportionality requirements reflected in HMRC’s own guidance.

On the face of it, the principle is straightforward: HMRC identifies a tax risk, requests information relevant to that risk and uses the information provided to determine whether further action is necessary. In practice, the position can be more complex.

Increasingly, advisers are encountering requests for extensive documentation at a very early stage, sometimes before HMRC has clearly explained the underlying concern being investigated. In other cases, requests are made after statutory enquiry windows have expired, with HMRC seeking information to help establish whether there is some basis to revisit a return. Schedule 36 was not intended to provide HMRC with an unrestricted right to access information simply because it might prove useful.

HMRC’s own guidance acknowledges that requests should be proportionate, reasonably required, relevant and linked to a specific compliance objective. Officers should be able to explain why information is needed and how it relates to the tax position under review. Where those connections are unclear, advisers should not assume that a request is automatically valid simply because it originates from HMRC.

When informal requests become problematic

One common misconception among taxpayers is that every request from HMRC carries legal force. In practice, many requests begin with an informal request for documents and information.   This may be presented as part of a compliance check or risk review, but they are not necessarily backed by statutory powers.

An informal request may still warrant a response, particularly where cooperation is likely to resolve matters quickly. However, taxpayers and advisers should understand that responding voluntarily is different from complying with a legally enforceable information notice. The risk is that informal requests can create pressure to disclose information without first considering whether the request is necessary, proportionate, or legally justified.

As HMRC’s compliance activity becomes increasingly data-driven, there is a risk that advisers fall into the role of information providers rather than strategic advisers.  A key responsibility of a professional adviser is to assess whether information being requested is genuinely relevant to the issue under consideration. The objective should not be to obstruct HMRC, but to ensure that the disclosure of documents and information remains focused on the specific tax risk being examined.

A good example of this is in a case we recently managed. HMRC’s Triage Team informally requested information relating to a corporation tax return after the statutory enquiry window had already closed. HMRC subsequently issued a formal Schedule 36 notice suggesting that they had a reason to suspect a loss of tax.

Following a challenge by our team, HMRC’s position was reviewed and as a result of a Statutory Review, the notice was ultimately cancelled. The compliance check was withdrawn entirely.

The significance of the case extends beyond the individual taxpayer involved. It highlights the importance of examining not only what information HMRC is requesting, but also the legal basis on which that request is being made.

Had the taxpayer simply complied without challenge, substantial amounts of information may have been disclosed despite HMRC lacking the necessary statutory footing to compel its production.

The risks of over disclosure

There is often an instinct to provide everything requested in the hope of bringing matters to a swift conclusion. While understandable, this approach can create unintended consequences; large volumes of documentation can generate further questions.  Unrelated information may prompt fresh areas of enquiry and historic transactions may be revisited despite having no relevance to the current compliance concern. This is particularly important when dealing with personal financial information.

We regularly see situations where HMRC request full bank statements on the basis they constitute statutory records. However, the position is rarely that straightforward. A personal bank account may contain a mixture of taxable receipts and entirely private expenditure. The presence of taxable transactions does not automatically mean the entire account becomes a statutory record requiring unrestricted disclosure.

Accountants and Tax advisers should question if HMRC has clearly demonstrated why the information is needed and whether the request is proportionate to the issue under review. In many circumstances, summaries, extracts or carefully redacted documents may be sufficient to address HMRC’s concerns without exposing extensive personal information that has no bearing on the tax position being checked.

Closed years and discovery assessments

Another area attracting increasing attention is HMRC’s use of information requests relating to years that would ordinarily be considered closed. Correspondence frequently references HMRC’s discovery powers under Section 29 of the Taxes Management Act 1970, but there is an important distinction that advisers should not overlook.

Section 29 is not a general fact-finding provision. It enables HMRC to assess additional tax where a valid discovery has been made. Increasingly, advisers report requests that appear designed to establish whether grounds for a discovery assessment might exist, rather than being supported by evidence that one already does.

This creates tension between HMRC’s desire to investigate, and the legislative safeguards intended to provide certainty for taxpayers once statutory time limits have passed. Where requests relate to closed years, advisers should carefully consider whether HMRC has adequately explained the basis for its concerns and whether the information sought is genuinely connected to a valid discovery position.

The wider issue is that HMRC’s compliance strategy continues to evolve. With access to increasingly sophisticated data sources, enhanced analytical tools and ongoing pressure to close the tax gap, HMRC is likely to make greater use enquiries, compliance interventions and information requests.

Much of this activity will be entirely legitimate. However, as enforcement powers are used more frequently, understanding their limits becomes more important. For accountants, this means moving beyond administrative compliance and actively assessing whether HMRC’s requests are properly framed.

The most effective outcomes are often achieved not through confrontation, but through informed engagement. Understanding the legal framework, challenging requests where necessary and ensuring disclosures remain proportionate can help protect taxpayers while maintaining a constructive relationship with HMRC.

As HMRC continues to test the boundaries of its information-gathering powers, advisers who understand where those boundaries lie will be best placed to protect clients, manage compliance risk and maintain constructive engagement with HMRC.