Is your business compliant with minimum employment law requirements?
Due to the particular challenges faced by businesses over the last few years, it’s natural that updating contracts of employment and compliance matters have not been prioritised.
At the same time however, several key changes in legislation have been introduced that affect employers. These include the Good Work Plan – which significantly increased the minimum information employers are required to provide to employees and workers – and changes to IR35, placing the obligation on employers to assess whether self -employed consultants engaged via a service company may be in deemed employment.
Employers are also now required to comply with requirements under the GDPR, including the requirement to provide employees, workers and consultants with a privacy notice, providing detailed information as to how they process their personal information.
And of course the way in which we work has changed irrevocably, with more employees than ever before working remotely or flexibly; this has brought its own, very specific challenges.
This guide to employment compliance sets out the key areas that you need to consider, to ensure that you are complying with minimum employment requirements.
Recruitment
Employers must ensure that they do not discriminate during the recruitment process. You must carefully consider your recruitment process to ensure its compliance. This starts with job advertisements, which must be focused on the actual requirements of the role. Care must be taken in the language that you use to avoid inadvertent indirect discrimination, for example, asking for a ‘recent graduate’ or someone that is “highly experienced” where this is not a genuine requirement.
It’s important that you don’t ask candidates about protected characteristics, for example, whether they are married or have or plan to have children. You should also not normally ask any questions regarding heath or disability except in very limited circumstances, for example where you are finding out whether they may need reasonable adjustments to the selection process.
Generally you should consider how you can ensure your selection process is objective, for example, using a panel of interviewers rather than an individual and using set interview questions.
You should also ensure that you have an appropriate job applicant privacy notice setting out your compliance with GDPR requirements and provide this to all job applicants.
Right to work checks
Prior to employment you must carry out a right to work check on all prospective employees to ensure that they have the legal right to work in the UK. This obligation and related guidance can be found here https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/right-to-work-checks-employers-guide. Until 5 April 2022 you can carry out an adjusted right to work check remotely if required. For further details see our blog https://parissmith.co.uk/blog/adjusted-covid-19-right-to-work-check-to-end-on-5-april-2022/.
Contract of employment: The Good Work Plan
Employers have always been required to provide key information to employees regarding their employment terms in a written document. This obligation is set out in S.1 Employment Rights Act 1996 and this document is therefore often known as a section 1 statement. It was previously limited to employees, and could be provided within two months’ of employment. Most employers provide this information in the form of a contract of employment.
The Good Work Plan introduced changes to the information that employers are required to provide all employees and workers employed from 6 April 2020 onwards.
From 6 April 2020 employers need to provide a written statement of particulars to all workers (and not just employees). The statement needs to be included in one document (which could be a section 1 statement or an employment contract) and needs to be provided to workers from the day they start employment.
Further information also needs to be given to workers over and above that which was previously required. The particulars cover a number of different working conditions such as:
- outlining working days, whether these can be varied and if so, how they may be varied;
- details of paid leave to which the worker is entitled;
- details of remuneration and benefits;
- probationary period information; and
- whether there are training entitlements provided by the employer, whether there is any mandatory training, and whether the worker must pay for any training themselves.
If you haven’t already implemented this change, you may also find our blog on this topic useful. https://parissmith.co.uk/blog/changes-employment-contracts/.
Staff Handbook/Employee Handbook and policies
All employers should have key policies in place to ensure compliance. These should include:
- – A disciplinary procedure, which should reflect the requirements set out in the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures (https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-code-of-practice-on-disciplinary-and-grievance-procedures )
- – A grievance procedure, which should reflect the requirements set out in the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures (https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-code-of-practice-on-disciplinary-and-grievance-procedures )
- – An equality and diversity policy, which should set out the employer’s commitment to equality and how it will ensure this in practice. This document and its implementation will often form a key element to an employer’s defence to a discrimination claim.
- – An anti-bullying and harassment policy, which sets out unacceptable treatment and how this will be addressed if it occurs. Again, this document and its implementation will often form a key element to an employer’s defence to a harassment claim.
- – A whistleblowing policy, which confirms how employees should blow the whistle should they become aware of any unlawful practice at work, and the protection provided to whistle-blowers
- – An anti-bribery and corruption policy: following the introduction of the Bribery Act 2010 it is essential that employers set out the expectations on employees to ensure compliance with this legislation.
- – A Health and Safety policy: this should set out how the employer manages key health and safety issues such as fire drills, accidents and first aid and safe use of equipment.
Most businesses will also need to have additional policies ranging from family friendly rights, flexible working requests to use of social media and information and communication systems.
Data Protection Compliance for Employers: GDPR and Data Protection Act obligations
The General Data Protection Regulation came into place in May 2018 and requires all organisations to demonstrate compliance with the data protection principles and to provide more information to data subjects about their processing activities than ever before.
Employers process significant personal data regarding their employees and job applicants. In addition to an internal data protection policy which sets out the standards that all staff are required to meet to ensure data protection compliance, all employers therefore need:
- An Employee Privacy Notice: this sets out the legal grounds on which employers will process information regarding their employees, the information processed, and key information about how this will be shared, stored, kept secure and employee’s rights to access data.
- A job applicant privacy notice: this sets out similar information for job applicants applying for a role with the organisation and should usually be available on the employer’s website. As there is no contract in place with job applicants, this information will usually be processed on the grounds of “legitimate interests” which means the employer should also carry out a risk assessment to justify the use of this information.
- Employment contracts – data protection wording in employment contracts needs to be reviewed to ensure compliance with GDPR.
- Regular audits – to review the data stored regarding employees and ensure that this is now processed in accordance with the GDPR principles, including appropriate retention periods.
- Data Protection Impact Assessments: where an employer processes particularly sensitive information, for example, location data from vehicle or mobile phone trackers, biometric data from fingerprint entry systems, or criminal records information, they will also need to complete a data protection impact assessment.
- Legitimate interests risk assessments: where an employer processes information relying on their legitimate interests to do so, for example, personal information and photographs for business development and marketing purposes, they should complete a legitimate interests risk assessment to ensure that they have struck an appropriate balance between the employers and the employee’s interests.
This is now a complex area. Additional considerations apply where the employer, or businesses that provide services to it, transfer employee data outside of the UK.
Further information and guidance for employers is available from the Information Commissioner . https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protection/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/ . Organisations can now be fined up to a maximum of £17.5 million or 4% of annual global turnover for non-compliance.
If you have not already updated your employment policies to reflect your obligations under the GDPR, you should act now to ensure you are compliant.
Engaging Consultants and Contractors
Many businesses now use self-employed consultants, either engaged as an individual, or via a limited company. It is important that employers carefully consider the status of these consultants and ensure that they have a clear written contract in place, setting out the agreed contractual terms.
Consultants and Contractors engaged via a limited company or intermediary – IR35 Compliance
Broadly speaking, there are three categories of employment status – employee, worker, and self-employed. The self-employed include sole traders and those working under a limited company or Personal Services Company. However, these definitions are not the same in employment law as they are in tax law. Unlike employment law, tax law only recognises two categories – employed and self-employed. Employment status is not a choice, it is determined based on the contract terms and crucially how these operate in practice.
IR35 is aimed at targeting contractors engaged through intermediaries, normally limited companies, where an individual is supplied to the client through a limited company and there is no direct contact between an individual and a client. At particular risk of IR35 are limited companies which have been set up to provide the services of a single contractor (usually the sole shareholder/director) which are known as Personal Service Companies (PSCs). These individuals are also commonly referred to as “off payroll workers”.
From 6 April 2021 medium and large sized private bodies which engage individual contractors or consultants through intermediaries or PSCs are required to determine their status.
The new rules are complex but essentially the question a company will need to ask, when using a personal service company to provide services to it, is “whether the person working under that arrangement (i.e. the worker) would be regarded as an employee if the services had been provided under a contract agreed directly between the worker and the company”.
In practice, this is likely to prove a tricky task, particularly with work relationships that have factors which both point to and point away from, IR35.
The Government has introduced a self-check tool to help companies with this assessment. Known as CEST (Check Employment Status for Tax) it can be found online and is free to use. However, this tool has limitations. While the CEST tool is a helpful starting point, companies who use PSC’s are at risk of penalties if they do not make assessments properly and should always seek professional advice to protect themselves and to sense check the results.
For further information please see our detailed guide to IR35. https://parissmith.co.uk/guide-to-ir35/
Consultants and Contractors engaged as individuals
IR35 does not apply to consultants and contractors engaged directly as an individual. However, employers still need to carefully consider their status and whether they could argue that they are in fact a worker or an employee, rather than genuinely self-employed.
There have been several key cases in this area over recent years, including the high profile Deliveroo and Uber decisions. For further information on the most recent decisions please see our blog https://parissmith.co.uk/blog/uber-lose-their-appeal-the-supreme-court-holds-that-uber-drivers-are-workers/
Employers should review their contractual terms with consultants to ensure that these are up to date and protect the employer from potential claims insofar as possible. They should also review their practical arrangements with consultants to ensure that they reflect a genuine self-employed arrangement.
National Minimum Wage
National Minimum Wage (NMW) rates are updated in April each year and can be found here https://www.gov.uk/national-minimum-wage-rates .
Varying rates apply depending on the employee’s age, with the national living wage applying to those aged 23 and over and lower rates applying for those aged 22 – 20, 20 – 18, under 18 and for qualifying apprentices.
Common compliance issues include:
- Employers not keeping correct records of hours worked and pay
- Employers failing to show hours on payslips when pay varies by time worked.
- Employers failing to pay for travelling time that is caught by the NMW
- Underpayment of apprentices due to not considering training time correctly
Since November 2017, HMRC inspectors have the power to take action against employers for record-keeping offences. It is a legal requirement for employers to provide payslips to all workers, and to show hours on payslips where these vary by time worked. Employers should ensure they are compliant to avoid being named and shamed or facing claims.
Working Time Regulations and Rest breaks
A commonly overlooked area of compliance is the rules relating to hours worked and rest breaks. Legally employees should not work in excess of a 48-hour working week on average unless they have signed a valid opt out from this restriction.
Employers should also ensure that employees have minimum rest breaks of at least 20 minutes a day where they work over 6 hours, a daily rest period of at least 11 hours and a weekly rest period of at least 24 hours.
Additional requirements apply for younger employees and where night work is involved. Ensuring appropriate rest breaks or compensatory rest is given for those working varying shift patterns is particularly complicated. Further information can be found at https://www.gov.uk/rest-breaks-work . Employers should review their current practices to ensure that they are compliant.
Holiday entitlement
It’s important to ensure that all employees are provided at least the statutory minimum holiday entitlement of 5.6 weeks per year, or 28 days for full time employees, including the 8 usual public holidays in England and Wales.
It is also important for employers to ensure that they are calculating holiday pay correctly. Following changes to the law in 2020, employers should now be calculating holiday pay based on the previous 52 weeks’ average pay where an employee’s pay varies depending on their hours or work done.
This includes where pay varies due to commission, compulsory or regular overtime and standby, call out and other similar payments.
This is based on the idea that a worker should not suffer financially for taking holiday. If you have employees on varying pay it is important to take these payments into account in your holiday payments to avoid liability for underpayments and connected claims. You can find further guidance as to how to calculate holiday pay here https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights/holiday-pay-the-basics
Holiday entitlement and pay is particularly difficult to calculate and apply in practice for zero hours workers. The old practice of “rolled up holiday pay” – paying an increased hourly rate to encapsulate an element of holiday pay is now unlawful. Holiday pay should now be paid for the time when annual leave is taken. Government guidance makes it clear that if a current contract still includes rolled-up pay, it needs to be re-negotiated. There is specific guidance for calculating holiday pay for employees without fixed hours or pay which can be found here https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/calculating-holiday-pay-for-workers-without-fixed-hours-or-pay
If you believe that you may have been paying holiday pay incorrectly, you should seek advice as to how best to resolve this issue and move to a correct method of payment.
Zero hours workers
Zero hours contracts or casual contracts as they are also known are essentially for on call workers. The employer is not obliged to offer work and the individual is not obliged to accept offers of work. However, the employer may have work available and calls the individual as and when this is the case. If the individual accepts, they work those hours under agreed terms.
Individuals working under zero hours contracts are entitled to the National Minimum Wage and statutory holiday entitlement and pay in the same way as other workers and employees.
Following recent changes, employers engaging zero hours workers cannot prevent those individuals from looking for work or accepting work elsewhere and individuals are entitled to ignore any clauses in their written terms that attempt to prevent this.
Further information regarding zero hours contracts can be found via ACAS https://www.acas.org.uk/zero-hours-contracts.
It is important that employers have appropriate written terms in place with all casual and zero hours workers, to make the nature of this relationship clear, and to comply with minimum obligations to provide written terms.
Remote and Hybrid Working:
As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, many businesses are now looking to move permanently to remote or hybrid working. If you have identified that hybrid or remote working will now be a permanent part of your business for the future, it is important that you take steps to formally implement this, and protect your business. This includes updating your contracts of employment and implementing appropriate home and remote working policies.
